DUI - DWAI Defense
Home Up DUI - Sentencing Grid Alcohol Education Grid Public Service Grid DUI - Sample Defenses

GUSTAFSON LAW OFFICE
Colorado Springs, Colorado    El Paso County
Robert D. Gustafson  *  Attorney at Law  *  Colorado Springs
COLORADO SPRINGS DUI - DWAI - DRUNK DRIVING DEFENSE

Email Attorney 

Attorney Vita

Phone (719) 260-1002
Fax (719) 260-1003  **  Toll Free (800) 410-1002
Hours Consultation Terms

Fees & Costs

Retainer Documents Driving Directions Maps to Attorney Travel * Trade Area * Courts
 

COLORADO SPRINGS DRUNK DRIVING DEFENSE
DWAI - DEAC - DUI DEFENSE COLORADO SPRINGS
Trial Practice 29+ years Colorado State Courts, Colorado Springs Municipal Court & Colorado DMV License Hearings & Appeals

ATTORNEY HOMEPAGE

Definitions & Jury Instructions BAC Presumptions DUI Court Proceedings Other Charges Mandatory Jail
Potential Defenses Factors Persistent Drunk Driver Injury or Death Child Abuse Charges Indecent Exposure Charges
DUI Sentencing * Client Preparation Driver License Restraint DUI Quick Index Relevant Statutes Vehicle Forfeiture Debate
Do I Need an Attorney? Attorney's Role
Colorado DMV License Defense DMV License Reinstatement  
  DMV Proceedings Accident Reports & Colorado DMV Forms
Colorado State Accident Report CSPD Accident Cold Report
ATTORNEY'S FEES AND COSTS
 
Public Service Supervision Agencies Alcohol Education Class List
Victim Impact Panel El Paso County - Colorado Springs
ATTORNEY POLICIES
  Cases Outside Colorado Springs - Travel
 No Pro Bono Assistance  *  No Installment Payment
 Legal Advice Limited to Clients - Not General Public
 Representation Now - Another Attorney or Self
 Attorney Representation & Declined Matters
 No Post Sentencing - Revocation or Appeal
 
attorney does not accept criminal & traffic cases after sentencing unless he defended the underlying case
non-acceptance includes probation revocation, deferred sentence revocation, parole violation or appeal  **  eligible collateral attack cases accepted
 

DUI Colorado Springs, DUI, DEAC or DWAI, drunk driving, blood test, breath test, refusal, BAC, .05 .08, .17, .20, roadside sobriety testing, roadsides, driving under the influence, driving while ability impaired, excessive alcohol, intoxicated, driver's license, DMV, El Paso County, lawyer, attorney, roadside sobriety tests, jail sentence, public service, alcohol classes, AA, antabuse Driver's license defense in Colorado DMV proceedings regarding driver license suspension, revocation, denial - Colorado Springs traffic & criminal defense attorney, Colorado, Court Teller County Colorado, DUI Teller County Colorado, DUI Cripple Creek Colorado, DUI Woodland Park Colorado, Court Teller County Colorado, Woodland Park Colorado, Cripple Creek Colorado, Teller County Colorado, DUI Castle Rock Colorado, Court Castle Rock Colorado, DUI Douglas County Colorado, Court Douglas County Colorado, DUI Kiowa Colorado, Court Kiowa Colorado, DUI Elbert County Colorado, Court Elbert County Colorado, DUI Colorado Springs, DUI, DWAI, DEAC, drunk driving, blood test, breath test, refusal, BAC, roadside sobriety testing, persistent drunk driver, driving, alcohol, 0.08, 0.17, 0.20, driving under the influence, driving while ability impaired, excessive alcohol, intoxicated, child abuse, license, DMV, lawyer, attorney, Colorado Springs, Colorado, DUI, DWAI, DEAC, blood alcohol test, breath test or refusal & roadside tests, excessive alcohol, persistent drunk driver, teenage drivers, DUI child abuse, license revocation, Colorado DUI defense lawyer 29+ years

Adobe Acrobat Reader version 5 or later is required to view .pdf files    Free Download

to facilitate loading speed, DUI matters have been separated into multiple pages

BASIC INFORMATION
please refer to the below links for basic information regarding defense of criminal & traffic cases

Right to Silence Search & Seizure Defendant Demeanor Bail Bond Independent Service Providers Advice from Laymen

1. Driving under the influence (DUI) means driving a vehicle when a person has consumed alcohol or one or more drugs, or a combination of alcohol and one or more drugs, which alcohol alone, or one or more drugs alone, or alcohol combined with one or more drugs affects the person to a degree that the person is substantially incapable, either mentally or physically, or both mentally and physically, to exercise clear judgment, sufficient physical control, or due care in the safe operation of a vehicle.  CRS 42-4-1301(1)(f)  In other states, this may be known as driving while intoxicated.

2. Driving while ability impaired (DWAI) means driving a vehicle when a person has consumed alcohol or one or more drugs, or a combination of both alcohol and one or more drugs, which alcohol alone, or one or more drugs alone, or alcohol combined with one or more drugs, affects the person to the slightest degree so that the person is less able than the person ordinarily would have been, either mentally or physically, or both mentally and physically, to exercise clear judgment, sufficient physical control, or due care in the safe operation of a vehicle.  CRS 42-4-1301(1)(g)

3. a.  Driving with excessive alcohol content (DEAC) means driving a vehicle when blood or breath alcohol concentration is .08 or more grams of alcohol per 100 ml of blood or 210 liters of breath; tested within 2 hours from time of driving.  CRS 42-4-1301(2)(a)
    b. 
"Baby DUI" is a term commonly used for underage drivers with a limited BAC.  It means driving a vehicle when blood or breath alcohol concentration is at least .02 but not more than .05 grams of alcohol per 100 ml of blood or 210 liters of breath; tested within 2 hours from time of driving.  CRS 42-4-1301(2)(a.5)  "Baby DUI" is a class A traffic infraction with adverse license consequences.  Refer also to vehicle forfeiture.

4.  Vehicle means any device which is capable of moving itself, or of being moved, from place to place upon wheels or endless tracks; but such term shall not include any farm tractor or any implement of husbandry designed primarily or exclusively for use and used in agricultural operations or any device moved by muscular power, or moved exclusively over stationary rails or tracks, or designed to move primarily through the air.  Source: COLJI 37(10) - that's a jury instruction.

        DUI law has changed from operating a motor vehicle to operating a vehicle.  Prosecutors are charging "DUI Bicycle"  Under the statutes and jury instruction definition, a defendant could be charged with riding his / her child's skateboard, tricycle or "big wheel."  Have a few beers before donning in-line skates - "DUI Roller Blades"  Absolutely absurd.  Call your state legislator. I haven't had occasion to research the issue, but I suspect whether a particular wheeled instrumentality will support conviction will be a factual question for the jury.  Jurors may not be terribly impressed with "DUI Big Wheel" - jury nullification may be the result.

5.  Driver means every person, including a minor driver under the age of twenty-one years, who drives or is in actual physical control of a vehicle.  CRS 42-1-102(27)

6. Operating a motorboat or sailboat while under the influence means operating a motorboat or sailboat or being in actual physical control when the operator is substantially incapable of safely operating the boat due to being under the influence of alcohol or drugs, or a combination thereof or have a blood alcohol concentration of .08 grams of alcohol per 100 ml of blood or per 210 liters of breath or greater.  CRS 33-13-108.1

 
INFERENCES FROM BREATH TEST OR BLOOD TEST ALCOHOL LEVELS
 

7. Inferences: the judge or jury may infer the following:  (aka permissive presumption - fact finder can presume or can ignore)
                                 alcohol quantity is reported as grams of alcohol per 100 ml blood or 210 liters of breath

 

    BAC below 0.050

inference of sobriety

    BAC 0.050 to 0.08

inference of impaired, but can be used as evidence of intoxication

    BAC 0.08 or above

inference of intoxication

Colorado Department of Health Regulations - breath or blood testing
BAC chemical testing is governed by health department regulation 5 CCR 1005-2  (breath testing or blood testing)

 

not jury inferences, but blood alcohol content thresholds

    BAC 0.170 or above

persistent drunk driver

    BAC 0.200 or above

mandatory jail first offense

 

On May 5, 2004 Colorado Legislature House Bill 04-1021 lowered the BAC limit from 0.10 to 0.08 regarding DUI presumption, DEAC threshold and driver's license excessive alcohol revocation - law effective date: July 1, 2004

 

Senate Bill 04-159 eliminated the requirement that a second specimen of breath, blood or urine be preserved for defense testing by an independent laboratory.  At present, a second specimen of blood is being collected and may be tested by a state certified independent laboratory as a check on the accuracy of the state's lab test results.  Pursuant to the legislatively authorized Department of Health Regulation changes, local law enforcement agencies are not collecting a silica jell second specimen of breath - second specimens of breath no longer exist for independent laboratory testing.

 

Intoxilyzer testing produces two specimen test results conducted on the same machine.  The state is purportedly being fair with drivers by producing an instantaneous re-test to verify accuracy of the intoxilyzer breath test results.  Analogy - broken speedometer of a car parked at the curb reads 70 mph.  Look again and second check of same faulty equipment still reads 70 mph.

 

Absent a second specimen, accuracy of the intoxilyzer machine can not be challenged by scientific evidence of specimen re-test results.  Lack of breath silica jell tube for testing by an independent laboratory is unfavorable to defense of alcohol charges.

 

8.  Prima facie case. The District Attorney Office may not dismiss a DUI driving under the influence, DWAI driving while ability impaired or DEAC driving with excessive alcohol content charge or reduce the charge to a non-alcohol offense unless a good faith representation is made by the prosecuting attorney that the attorney could not establish a prima facie case if the defendant were brought to trial on the original alcohol-related or drug-related offense.  That means the prosecutor represents to the Court that the state could not produce sufficient evidence to withstand a motion for judgment of acquittal at the end of the prosecution's case in chief.

 

1. First Appearance.  
        a.  The DUI ticket is the charging document and advises defendant of the charges filed. The ticket contains a date and time defendant must appear in Court for first appearance, where defendant will be advised of the nature of the charges and possible penalties. At that time defendant will also be asked how he / she wishes to proceed with his / her case. If defendant fails to appear, a warrant will be issued for his / her arrest. If this office has been hired, the attorney will take care of the first appearance for the client, and the client need not appear in Court unless I notify you.
        b.  We are all human - periodically the law enforcement officer(s) make(s) an error on the summons.  Some errors are sufficient to deprive the court of jurisdiction to hear the case.  If an error exists, it may be worth making a big ta-do because it may result in dismissal or a more favorable plea offer.

 
 

OTHER CHARGES COMMONLY FILED WITH DUI - DEACDWAI

Careless Driving Reckless Driving Speeding Hit & Run
Driving Under Restraint No Operator's License Eluding Police Vehicular Eluding
Stop Sign or Stop Light School Bus Stop Compulsory Insurance Indecent Exposure
Speed Contest - Drag Racing Exhibition of Speed or Acceleration Contest
Child Abuse Vehicular Assault or Vehicular Homicide Weaving (roadways laned for traffic)
 

2. Court Appointed Counsel
        a.  If jail may be imposed for any period, including offenses less than 6 months jail, the state has an obligation to appoint an attorney for an indigent (poor) defendant.  An indigent defendant has a constitutional right to appointed counsel "only when, if he loses, he may be deprived of his physical liberty."  Lassiter v. Department of Social Services, 452 U.S. 18, 27, 101 S.Ct. 2153, 2159, 68 L.Ed.2d 640, 645 (1981); see Argersinger v. Hamlin, 407 U.S. 25, 92 S.Ct. 2006, 32 L.Ed.2d 530 (1972 (petty offense case); see also Stern v. County Court, 773 P.2d 1074 (Colo. 1989) (attorney must be provided for indigent defendants accused of crimes if imprisonment may be imposed).
        b.  The defendant may not choose his / her own lawyer.  When an appointment is made, the court appoints the Public Defender's Office and if there is a conflict due to multiple defendants, the court a member of the private defense bar who has contracted with the state for court appointments.
        c.  If the prosecutor waives jail, the state's obligation to provide counsel is negated.  When an indigent defendant is not actually sentenced to a term of imprisonment, due process does not require the appointment of counsel.  See Scott v. Illinois, 440 U.S. 367, 99 S.Ct. 1158, 59 L.Ed.2d 383 (1979).

 
3.  Entry of Plea & Demand for Trial.  
        a.  In El Paso County, initial appearance hearings are held in the First Appearance Center.  The case then transfers to a judge's division.
        b.  Under the speedy trial rule, trial must be provided within 6 months from entry of not guilty plea.

        Speedy & Public Trial: C.R.Crim.P. 48(b), CRS 18-1-405, Article II Section 16 of the Colorado Constitution and Amendment 6 to the U.S. Constitution.  See also 4th, 5th & 14th Amendments to the U.S. Constitution, and Article II, Sections 7, 18 & 25 of the Colorado Constitution

        Speedy trial commences on the date of filing the not guilty plea. Harrison v. District Court, 192 Colo. 351, 559 P.2d 225 (1977), Rodman v. Adams County Court, 694 P.2d 871 (Colo. App. 1984).  This can become important as to speedy trial expiration if the case is transferred to division and advisement + oral not guilty plea is delayed.

        c.  Demand must be made for jury trial:
1.  Misdemeanor offense cases - not guilty plea entered

        a.  Jury trial is free if jail may be imposed in excess of 6 months upon conviction of any charge.

        b.  If potential jail is limited to 6 months or less for each charge, a jury demand must be accompanied by a $25 jury deposit within 10 days from entry of the not guilty plea.   CRS 16-10-109, C.R.Crim.P. 23.  Although local county court judges will likely grant a jury demand without payment of the jury deposit, absent timely jury deposit payment,  prosecutors may take the issue to the district court seeking a writ of prohibition.  In the likely event of adverse ruling, subsequent jury deposit payment would be outside the 10 day limitation and jury trial right would be lost.  This attorney will timely pay the jury deposit to avoid the issue and preserve the client's right to jury trial.

        c.  Driving While Ability Impaired, CRS 42-4-1302(1)(b) has been determined not a petty offense and no jury deposit is required under CRS 16-10-109, C.R.Crim.P. 23.  Refer to Byrd v. Stavely, 113 P.3d 1273 (Colo. App 2005)  This is the exception to the 6+ month potential jail jury deposit rule.

        d.  Standard number of jurors is 6, defendant may request 3 jurors.  C.R.Crim.P. 23, Colorado Constitution Article 2 §§16, 23, CRS 16-10-101, CRS 18-1-406

2.  Petty offense cases - not guilty plea entered

        a.  Petty offenses are crimes or offenses punishable not in excess of imprisonment for six months and a fine of not more than $500, or a combination of imprisonment and fine within such limits. Robran v. People, 173 Colo. 378 (Colo. 1971); Austin v. City and County of Denver, 170 Colo. 448, 462 P.2d 600 (Colo. 1969)

        b.  There is no constitutional right to a jury trial for a petty offense.

        c.  The statutory right to jury trial in a petty offense is established in CRS 16-10-109, however the statute identifies petty offenses as an offense classified as a petty offense or defined as an offense which is punishable by imprisonment other than in a correctional facility for not more than six months, or by a fine of not more than five hundred dollars, or by both such imprisonment and fine. 

        d.  Based upon statutory limitations of potential jail not more than 6 months, a jury demand must be accompanied by a $25 jury deposit within 10 days from entry of the not guilty plea.   CRS 16-10-109, C.R.Crim.P. 23.  Refer to ¶3(c)(1) above regarding timely payment.

       e.  Standard number of jurors is 3, defendant may request 6 jurors.  C.R.Crim.P. 23, Colorado Constitution Article 2 §§16, 23, CRS 16-10-101, CRS 18-1-406  Counsel requests 6 jurors.

        f.  An El Paso County Court case appealed to the District Court resulted in a ruling that jury trial is a right in an MIP prosecution (underage possession / consumption) which does not fit the statutory definition of petty offense for purpose of jury trial right, however counsel would argue that right.

        d.  The right to jury trial is an important right which should never be waived unless for tactical reasons after consulting with counsel.
 

4. No Pre-Trial Conference.  Pursuant to Colorado Supreme Court Chief Justice Directive 08-05 (benchmarks) which pertains to delay prevention, performance review of judges and retention (judge's jobs), in May, 2008 the courts in El Paso County again changed policy.  DUI, traffic offense and misdemeanor cases are no longer set for pre-trial conference.  At the time of first appearance, attorney cases are now set for contested proceedings - subpoena duces tecum return, motion hearing, readiness hearing and jury trial.  Courts will not set motions hearing absent filing of a motion, therefore an initial motion to suppress will be filed with entry of appearance.  Prior to contested hearing dates, the defense attorney may negotiate with prosecutors to discuss possible alternatives and attempt to reach an agreement to dispose of the case.  This is called plea bargaining. Clients have inquired "What's a deferred sentence?"  Refer to the link for information.  Are prosecutors concerned with their statistics? If a plea bargain is obtained which is acceptable to the client, the case is dismissed or set for sentencing.  If a plea bargain is not obtained which is acceptable to the client, the case is set for motion hearings or trial, or both. Locally the courts require a defendant's presence unless an out of state resident.  Offer of flat dismissal is unlikely in most cases.  The goal is to procure a disposition with which the defendant can live, e.g. not going to jail or not losing the driver's license, or perhaps a deferred sentence to a lesser charge which would not be reflected on the consumer driving abstract.  If a plea bargain is obtained which is acceptable to the client, contested hearings are vacated and the case is dismissed or set for sentencing.  If a plea bargain is not obtained which is acceptable to the client, the case continues to contested hearings and trial.  Locally the courts require a defendant's presence unless an out of state resident.  Refer to factors which attorney uses in determining whether a case is likely to settle or proceed to trial.

        a.  Local courts are setting trial dates 60 days out from initial appearance - similar to domestic violence fast track.  This is a form of docket control for the courts.  Convenient for those who set policy, but in fairness, El Paso County Court is inundated with cases.

        b.  This court policy places a heavy burden upon defense counsel and defendants.  Plea negotiations should not take place until the attorney has an understanding of the case - receipt of a copy of the DA Office file (which includes summons & complaint(s) law enforcement officer notes and reports, accident report, Colorado driving record & witness list), plus client factual interview and receipt of driving records.  If an alcohol charge is alleged, discovery to be procured includes roadside sobriety checklist, lab reports, DOH lab certifications and defense counsel blood BAC re-test by independent laboratory.  If a driving under restraint charge is included, discovery to be procured includes a DMV discovery packet & file.  This takes time.  If the case can not be settled, a very short window exists for investigator interviews and for counsel to file supplemental motions & briefs, witness endorsements, exhibit endorsements, jury instructions, and theory of defense.  The court may not grant continuance of hearings.

        c.  Even though contested proceedings are set, attorney settlement fees may be quoted.  If the client rejects the plea offer, trial fees and costs will be due at the time client elects to proceed to trial - no exceptions.  Cases will proceed to jury trial within 2 months from initial court appearance.  Be aware of this very short window of time.  Counsel will approach cases outside of El Paso County similarly.

        d.  Given the short amount of time between initial appearance and trial setting, this attorney would prefer to prepare each case for trial at the outset.  Since this is a new policy, counsel will give it an opportunity to see how timing works, but the court policy may simply result in the need for trial preparation in each case at the time of representation commencement.  Settlement fees may become a thing of the past.

 

5. Motions Hearings.  Counsel may file any of several motions available.  DUI most common motions:

        a. Discovery Motion. This is a request to discover information in order to prepare an adequate defense
        b.
Motion in Limine. This is a motion to exclude evidence from DUI trial on the basis of evidentiary or statutory grounds.  An example would be a breath or blood test which is not defendant's but mislabeled; and which could prejudice the jury without having any importance on the issue of guilt or innocence.
        c.
Motion to Suppress. This is a motion to exclude evidence from DUI trial on the basis of violation of constitutional rights.  An example would be a random stop for the purpose of an evidentiary fishing expedition.  Absent probable cause (reason to believe defendant engaged in a crime) for the stop or arrest, evidence obtained therefrom may not be used against defendant.  Similarly, forced confessions or statements may not be used.  There are many other arguments which may be available in DUI cases.  With limited exceptions, defendant must be present in court for motion hearings.

 

6. Trial.

        At a trial, guilt or innocence will be determined, and it must be decided unanimously (all jurors agree).  Every defendant has the right to a trial by jury of 6 persons, or to the judge alone.  The right to trial by jury should never be waived (given away) without advice of counsel; it is an important right.  At DUI trial, the prosecution must prove each and every element of the crime(s) charged beyond a reasonable doubt.  Every defendant is presumed innocent unless and until the prosecution proves guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.  Every defendant may remain silent, or may testify if he / she chooses. Defense may call witnesses and make them come to court by subpoena.  Every defendant may confront and cross-examine witnesses against him / her.  A trial on a DUI charge is a criminal trial with all rights attached. If defendant is found not guilty, the case is concluded.  If defendant is found guilty of any charge, including a lesser charge of DWAI, the case is set for sentencing.  Defendant must be present in court for a trial.  Under some circumstances, the court may proceed to trial without the presence of the defendant, but that's a bad idea from defense perspective.

 

IMPORTANT
KNOWLEDGE

Trial is necessary to avoid mandatory jail required by Colorado law under the below circumstances
          1.  BAC is 0.20+ first offense or subsequent offense
          2.  second or subsequent alcohol related traffic offense

                        BAC = first or subsequent offenses. 
                        Prior DUI offenses include out of state convictions.
                        Jail alternatives may include GPS, ankle bracelet or day reporting if it can be negotiated
                        Work release would likely be granted
                             defendant pays daily fee for alternatives & work release

2008 DUI License & Interlock Legislation  House Bill 08-1194

BAC 0.17+  =  persistent drunk driver mandatory interlock

For additional information regarding mandatory minimum + presumptive maximum sentencing,
please refer to the grid web page links in ¶6 immediately below - sentencing.

 
 

7 Sentencing:  DUI can carry jail.  DUI 1st with BAC in excess of 0.20 and 2nd / subsequent offenses carry mandatory jail.

        At DUI sentencing, the Court has the options of imposing a fine, court costs, jail, alcohol education or therapy, public service, alcohol anonymous meetings, or any other condition reasonably related to rehabilitation. Defendant must be present in court for sentencing.

        A DUI evaluation is conducted by the probation department before sentencing to determine the influence of alcohol in defendant's life, and a report is made to the court. The judge is free to accept or reject the recommendations when imposing the sentence. 

        When making DUI sentencing recommendations, the probation department has become highly reliant upon the Department of Health Regulation 6 CCR 1008-1(8.4)  (Code of Colorado Regulations) which recommends alcohol education and therapy based upon BAC and offender status (first or multiple).  This DOH regulation can now be reduced to a grid - to view please refer to the Alcohol Education & Therapy Grid
        As with alcohol education, useful public service - aka community service - can now be reduced to a grid based upon Colorado statutes.  CRS 42-4-1301(9)  Statutory Public Service Grid
        Unfortunately, courts today are more likely to follow the probation department's recommendations than in times past.  It seems the larger the county, the less individual discretion is exercised.  This concept is otherwise known as a grist mill.

DOH regulations and statutory schemes  can now be reduced to grids

 

 
 
 
 

QUICK INDEX ** DRUNK DRIVING DEFENSE AT A GLANCE
ALCOHOL SENTENCING * ALCOHOL EDUCATION
USEFUL PUBLIC SERVICE * VICTIM IMPACT PANEL

Grid pages provide a quick summary of jail (some mandatory), alcohol education & public service

2008 Pending DUI License & Interlock Legislation  HB 08-1194

 
 
 
 
DUI and DEAC Sentencing DWAI Sentencing DMV License Loss or Restrictions
Sentencing Grid Deferred Sentencing Vehicle Forfeiture - legislative debate
Relevant Statutes & Regulations Synopsis - BAC 0.20+ Victim Impact Panel - Colorado Springs MADD
Alcohol Education Sentencing Grid Alcohol Education & Therapy Alcohol Education - Non Driving - MIP
Public Service Sentencing Grid Public Service Supervision Agencies Traffic Safety Classes Petty Theft Classes
Alcoholics Anonymous In Patient Treatment Domestic Violence Classes & Anger Management
McMaster Clinic Detox Facility DMV Accident Reports & Forms Mental Health Completion Forms

 

        Each case is different; judges impose sentence based upon the facts of each case.. For additional information regarding mandatory minimum + presumptive maximum DUI sentencing, please refer to the grid web pages - see drunk driving at a glance.

 

 

        In El Paso County, jail can be but is not usually imposed on a DUI first offense if the case is properly presented, the blood or breath alcohol concentration is below 0.20 and the facts are not aggravated.  If the driver refused a chemical test, the El Paso County District Attorney Office policy tends to be inflexible treating the case as a non-negotiable DUI.  Commercial Driver License - CDL - would complicate negotiations.

 

 

 

 

        On a DUI second offense or BAC .20+ first offense / subsequent anticipate, imposition of 30+ days jail sentence .
        The El Paso County District Attorney Office has adopted a policy in DUI cases that second offenders should spend at least 30-60 days straight jail time or 1.5 - 2 times the number of days with work release or some other combination with day reporting.  I have seen occasion where only straight jail was offered - work release or day reporting was excluded by the DDA in negotiations.
        Mandatory minimum jail sentences imposed by state law (statute)
        On September 25, 2001 Colorado law changed significantly.  Jail is now mandatory if the BAC is above 0.20, and changes were made regarding second or subsequent offenses.  
        For several years, Judge Peters in Teller County has incarcerated on a first offense if the BAC was 0.20 or greater.  In cases with extenuating circumstances, Judge Peters may not have imposed jail, but effective Sept. 25, 2001 all judges are required by statute to incarcerate for a minimum of 10 days.

 

 

         A third offense can draw 4-9 months jail.  

 

          When a defendant is charged with DUI 4th offense and above, take a look at maximum jail under the statutes - the defendant best think about winning at motions hearing or  trial.  

 

          Bear in mind these are generalizations, and may change in any case based upon the facts and circumstances surrounding the DUI case.  

        Prior Offenses:  In times past, prior DUI convictions were facts which the prosecutor was required to establish beyond a reasonable doubt at trial.  To avoid prejudice, defense counsel would move for a bifurcated trial.  Trial was held on the issue of guilt without mention of any prior DUI offense(s).  If convicted a "mini trial" would then be held on the issue of prior DUI conviction(s).  As with so many issues in DUI, that has changed unfavorably for the defendant.  Prior DUI offenses are deemed a sentencing enhancer and determined by the judge at sentencing hearing.

        For sentencing purposes concerning convictions for second and subsequent DUI offenses, prima facie proof of a defendant's previous DUI convictions shall be established when the prosecuting attorney and the defendant stipulate to the existence of the prior conviction or convictions or the prosecuting attorney presents to the court a copy of the driving record of the defendant provided by the department of revenue of this state, or provided by a similar agency in another state, that contains a reference to such previous conviction or convictions or presents an authenticated copy of the record of the previous conviction or judgment from any court of record of this state or from a court of any other state, the United States, or any territory subject to the jurisdiction of the United States. The court shall not proceed to immediate sentencing when there is not a stipulation to prior convictions or if the prosecution requests an opportunity to obtain a driving record or a copy of a court record. The prosecuting attorney shall not be required to plead or prove any previous convictions at trial, and sentencing concerning convictions for second and subsequent offenses shall be a matter to be determined by the court at sentencing.  CRS 42-4-1301(7)(c)(II)

        Absent stipulation of the defendant, I believe out of state records raise constitutional issues of full faith and credit - exemplification of the record rather than certification.  That difference could be significant, but is subject to legal research.

        MISDEMEANOR and TRAFFIC CASES - JAIL SENTENCE IMPOSED

        A defendant may qualify for work release.  That means the defendant would be released from custody in time to go to work and would be due back to the detention facility shortly after finishing work.

Work Release

        Defendant must provide a letter on company letterhead verifying days and hours of employment.
        The local jail - CJC has a maximum release policy - 12 hours per day, 6 days per week.  COMCOR
work release facility did not have a maximum release policy the last I checked.  Call the jail for specific information.
        To verify employment status defendant must be available by land line telephone - not cell phone.
        To be able to drive to and from work, defendant must provide a current driving record reflecting valid driving privileges plus insurance currently in effect.
        The cost is approximately $20 per day

Home Detention - Ankle Bracelet

        A DUI defendant may qualify for home detention - also known as ankle bracelet.  Courts generally leave ankle bracelet determination to the sheriff's office or COMCOR.  However, courts are becoming more involved in home detention orders due to mandatory jail time and over-crowding.

Day Reporting

        A DUI defendant may qualify for day reporting.  That means defendant would report between 1 - 5 times per week to an agency which monitors compliance with conditions of probation and may request random breath, blood or urine samples to check for alcohol or drugs.
        The cost is approximately $6 per day report.

    To verify employment status a defendant must be available by land line telephone - not cell phone.
    To be able to drive to and from work, a defendant must provide a current driving record reflecting valid driving privileges plus insurance currently in effect.

8. Preparation for Sentencing.

        In a DUI criminal case, counsel looks for facts which may lead to dismissal of charges or not guilty verdict. Plea negotiations are affected by weaknesses in the DA's case.  

        "Shoot for the best - plan for the worst."  It is also wise to plan for other contingencies; conviction of an alcohol offense. Anticipating you may subsequently face a judge, to prepare for the most favorable sentencing result a defendant should immediately commence minimums of useful public service (aka community service) plus an alcohol education class at a Colorado certified program. Level 2 is usually recommended by probation department; Level 1 recommendations are generally received only if the BAC is below 0.08.
 
 
DUI SENTENCING * ALCOHOL EDUCATION
USEFUL PUBLIC SERVICE * VICTIM IMPACT PANEL

Grid pages provide a quick summary of jail (some mandatory), alcohol education & public service
Please refer to DUI drunk driving defense at a glance for grids, alcohol education & public service self help ¶ 6 above

 
****************************** ****************************** ******************************
 
If a DUI defendant has an alcohol or drug problem, he / she  should also immediately commence attending at least 1 AA or NA meeting per week. Support is available.
refer to
Remedial Quick Links

 
DMV Addresses and Links Driving Abstracts and Records DMV Point Structure On-Line Colorado Driving Records
Driver License & Hearing Defense DMV Appeal Legal Research Selected Statutes & Regs "Red" License & Interlock Devices
Insurance Actions SR-22 Insurance Habitual Traffic Offender Interstate Compact Accident Reports & DMV Forms
DMV Hearing
Defense
DMV Appeal
statute of limitations

Driving in Colorado is a constitutionally protected privilege, but nevertheless a privilege which may be lost.  Multiple statutes can cause loss of driving privileges for different driver behavior.  Drivers are entitled to a DMV hearing.  In some circumstances the right to hearing precedes potential DMV adverse action; under other Colorado traffic laws the adverse order is entered, then the driver is provided notice of the adverse action and right to request subsequent hearing.  If hearing has been held or a DMV final order has otherwise entered and the Colorado driver's license or Colorado driving privileges have been suspended, revoked or denied, the driver's remaining recourse is appeal to the District Court.  DMV appeal is subject to a statute of limitations.  Right to appeal may be lost if the driver delays.  Upon final order in the District Court, either party make take the case on appeal to the Colorado Court of Appeals.  Refer to links for information.

CSPD Accident Cold Report    due within 72 hours of accident
obtain hardcopy cold report from CSPD Police Operations Center
State of Colorado On-Line Accident Report
accident report obsolete 8/4/04 unless no officer accident report
 
Point Structure Driver's License Hearings & Adverse Actions
DMV Address and Links
 
 Colorado Springs Regional Service Center
 
On-Line Colorado Driving Record

Summary of actions the DMV may take against driver's licenses or privileges to drive in Colorado.  It is not intended to be all inclusive, however does contain external links where a website visitor may read statutes verbatim which may impact his / her case  

Accident Reports and Other DMV Forms 

Interlock Device

Habitual Traffic Offender

CSPD Accident Cold Report  
Colorado State Accident Report on-line
Colorado State Accident Report hardcopy
DMV - Evidence of Insurance
DMV - Affidavit of Financial Responsibility
DMV - FRA - Release from Liability
DMV - FRA - Waiver of Security - Financial Responsibility
DMV - Promissory Note Contract
DMV - Affidavit - Out of State Residency - FRA SR-22 Avoidance

Breath testing equipment installed in your vehicle at your expense.  Voluntary Installation - excessive alcohol revocation & drivers losing their license one year +.  Involuntary Installation - 2nd / subsequent offenders or habitual offender

SR-22 Insurance
Colorado Department of Health Regulations
breath or blood testing
Interstate Compact Hit and Run Driving Under Restraint
State of Colorado accident report obsolete 8/4/04 * police now verify insurance at the accident scene
refer to above link for information, forms, state on-line accident report and CSPD Cold Report
 

        Under Colorado law, if the insurance information of a driver was not included in a law enforcement traffic accident report, a Colorado State Accident Report must be submitted to the DMV within 10 days of an accident. CRS 42-4-1609 Also by statute, statements by a driver in the accident report may not be used in conjunction with any court proceedings, criminal or civil, except that the DMV may disclose the identity of a person involved in an accident when such identity is not otherwise known or when such person denies his or her presence at such accident. CRS 42-4-1610, CRS 42-7-504.  The primary purpose of filing the accident report is to comply with state law, and to provide evidence of insurance on the vehicle - thereby avoiding an FRA suspension.- refer to link for information.  If any of the below charges are alleged, a driver should consult with his or her defense attorney regarding exercise of constitutional privileges before making any oral or written statement.

Summary of criminal actions, defenses and penalties which may result from loss of driver license or privileges to drive in Colorado - driving under suspension, revocation or denial and driving after judgment prohibited

Drivers licensed in Colorado who have traffic problems out of state and drivers licensed out of state who have Colorado traffic problems
 

 

1.  Driver's License Actions

        Quick summary of actions the DMV may take against driver's licenses or privileges to drive in Colorado.
        Not intended to be all inclusive, however does contain external links where a website visitor may read statutes verbatim which may impact your case.

2. DMV - Address Change

        If any driver has not given the DMV your current address, do immediately. Address Change Form  The DMV is only required to provide notices to the last address in their records. Drivers may request a hearing or provide a change of address to any DMV office. 
        In Colorado Springs area:  DMV Addresses and Links page

3. Excessive Alcohol Content - Regular Driver's License - Revocation or denial CRS 42-2-126   

4. Excessive Alcohol Content - Commercial Driver's License - CDL - Revocation or denial CRS 42-2-126

5. Refusal to Submit to Blood or Breath Testing - revocation or denial.  CRS 42-2-126 - no time limit

6. Penalties and Procedure. Regular license excessive BAC, CDL excessive BAC, BAC refusal

7. State of Driver's License Issuance - Colorado DUI stop - Seizure.

Colorado License
        Most likely the driver's license was physically seized by the arresting officer at the time of DUI arrest if the driver refused chemical testing or had a breath test by intoxilyzer - aka breathalyzer. 
        If the driver elected and completed a DUI blood test, the license probably was not seized as the officer did not know the results, but will be seized at the revocation hearing if adverse ruling enters.
        If the driver wins the DMV hearing, the license will be returned with no adverse consequences
        If the driver loses the DMV hearing, unless in possession of a valid out of state driver's license prior to revocation of the Colorado license, he / she may not drive anywhere in the U.S.
        Refer to DMV hearings - adverse action page

Out of state license
        Colorado law provides that an out of state license be seized by Colorado DMV. But see State v. Kivell, 463 N.E.2d 52, 55 (Ohio App. 1983) and Commonwealth v. Levy, 194 Pa.Super. 390, 169 A.2d 596, 598 (1961) - deciding whether a trial judge could seize an out of state license pursuant to DWI state law, ruling entered that a license issued by another state can only be suspended or revoked by it.  Put another way - a state can deny privileges within it's boundaries and send notice to the home state, but what a state didn't grant, the state can't take away.  The license can not be seized because it is valid in the home state and other states absent adverse action by the home state.  This issue has not yet been tested at the Colorado appellate level.  Hmmm.... but none of my clients have wanted to spend the money on an appeal - so.... police and the DMV continue to seize out of state licenses.  Every attorney is awaiting a client with the resources and resolve to test the law on appeal.
        Most likely the driver's license was physically seized by the arresting officer at the time of arrest if the driver refused chemical testing or had a breath test. 
        If the driver elected and completed a blood test, the license probably was not seized as the officer did not know the results, but will be seized at the revocation hearing if adverse ruling enters.
        A Colorado revocation or denial will prevent the driver from lawfully driving in Colorado on an out of state license. 
        Regarding possibility of a duplicate foreign license which may be valid outside Colorado, please refer to the Interstate Compact page
        Refer to DMV hearings - Adverse Action page

8. Point Suspension
        Point system
- adult, provisional, minor and chauffeur (CDL)
                How many point do I have and at what number will I be suspended?
        Points assessed for common tickets
        Point suspension - base periods of license loss
        Points - out of state license - Colorado conviction
        Points - Colorado license - out of state conviction

9. Application for Driver's License in Another State

10. Other License Proceedings

a. Insurance related statutes
         Numerous traffic problems which require SR-22 insurance
       
Colorado law requires insurance companies to report all vehicle policies. If a vehicle becomes uninsured, the owner will receive a notice and must provide evidence of insurance to the DMV with 45 days or the vehicle license plates will be seized.
        Each above DMV proceeding is independent of the other and can be entered simultaneously.

b. Driving privileges may be lost for multiple alcohol or other major offenses
        2 alcohol convictions within a period of 5 years
        1 year loss.
        3 alcohol convictions in your lifetime
        2 year loss.
        Habitual offender proceedings (3 major offenses within 7 years) 
        5 year license loss

c. Interlock Device - refer to link for additional information        
        Breath testing equipment installed in your vehicle at your expense
        Voluntary Installation - excessive alcohol revocation & drivers losing their license one year +
        Involuntary Installation - 2nd / subsequent offenders or habitual offender

AUTOMATED TRAFFIC ENFORCEMENT - TRAFFIC CAMERAS
relevant links

Local Traffic Cams Automated Traffic Enforcement Traffic Cam Information Colorado Statute DMV Point Structure Traffic Defense

DRIVING UNDER RESTRAINT
DRIVING AFTER REVOCATION PROHIBITED
SUSPENSION, REVOCATION OR DENIAL and HABITUAL OFFENDER
Refer to Above Link for Information

 

$10,000 bail bond not to be released while the case is pending
plus mandatory jail sentence if convicted

If that catches your attention, follow the above title link to a summary of criminal actions, defenses and penalties which may result from continued operation of a vehicle after loss of driver's license or privileges to drive in Colorado.  Driving without getting caught?  refer to Murphy's law.  And we all know that is followed by Mrs. Murphy's addendum.

Southern Colorado law enforcement agencies linked in sophisticated equipment picture

VEHICLE FORFEITURE
legislative debate

 

        If relevant, refer to the below links.  Such charges are indeed filed in conjunction with DUI when law enforcement alleges the defendant was urinating - aka "draining the radiator," masturbating in a parked car or engaged in sex in secluded, yet public place.  Such charges have consequences which can be quite serious.  If patronizing a prostitute or "lady of the evening" when apprehended, prostitution may also be charged in conjunction with DUI.  For all practical purposes, if charged in the same criminal prosecution as DUI, DEAC or DWAI, public urination, public masturbation, public intercourse, public fellatio or public cunnilingus allegations necessitate jury trial due to long term consequences.  Refer to the links if this is relevant to your case.

Indecency webpage
Indecent exposure
 
Public indecency 
 
 
 
 
 

Sex offender webpage
Statutorily defined sex offenses
     indecent exposure is included, public indecency is not includedt
Registered sex offender

     overkill in this type of circumstance, but very real
Special rules - sex offense  
    
charged and conviction or deferred sentence enters to any offense
Sex offender registry

CHILD ABUSE CRIMINAL CHARGES

        Law enforcement officers are now charging child abuse when a minor child is in the vehicle and the driver is charged with DUI, DEAC or DWAI.  If the law enforcement officer fails to charge, the District Attorney office will likely file a motion to amend and add the charge pursuant to C.R.Crim.P. 7(e).  Prosecutors view this as a serious criminal charge.  Having a child or children in the vehicle is a serious complication to a drunk driving case even if no accident or injury is involved.

CRS 18-6-401. Child Abuse.

        (1)        (a) A person commits child abuse if such person causes an injury to a child's life or health, or permits a child to be unreasonably placed in a situation that poses a threat of injury to the child's life or health, or engages in a continued pattern of conduct that results in malnourishment, lack of proper medical care, cruel punishment, mistreatment, or an accumulation of injuries that ultimately results in the death of a child or serious bodily injury to a child.
                    (b) intentionally omitted
                    (c) A person commits child abuse if, in the presence of a child, or on the premises where a child is found, or where a child resides, the person engages in the manufacture or attempted manufacture of a controlled substance, as defined by section 18-18-102(5), or possesses ephedrine, pseudoephedrine, or phenylpropanolamine, or their salts, isomers, or salts of isomers, with the intent to use the product as an immediate precursor in the manufacture of a controlled substance. 
        (2) In this section, "child" means a person under the age of sixteen years.
        (3) The statutory privilege between patient and physician and between husband and wife shall not be available for excluding or refusing testimony in any prosecution for a violation of this section.
        (4) No person, other than the perpetrator, complicitor, coconspirator, or accessory, who reports an instance of child abuse to law enforcement officials shall be subjected to criminal or civil liability for any consequence of making such report unless he knows at the time of making it that it is untrue.
        (5) Deferred prosecution is authorized for a first offense under this section unless the provisions of subsection (7.5) of this section or section 18-6-401.2 apply.
        (6) Repealed.
        (7)        (a) Where death or injury results, the following shall apply:
                            (I) When a person acts knowingly or recklessly and the child abuse results in death to the child, it is a class 2 felony except as provided in paragraph (c) of this subsection (7).
                            (II) When a person acts with criminal negligence and the child abuse results in death to the child, it is a class 3 felony.
                            (III) When a person acts knowingly or recklessly and the child abuse results in serious bodily injury to the child, it is a class 3 felony.
                            (IV) When a person acts with criminal negligence and the child abuse results in serious bodily injury to the child, it is a class 4 felony.
                            (V) When a person acts knowingly or recklessly and the child abuse results in any injury other than serious bodily injury, it is a class 1 misdemeanor.
                            (VI) When a person acts with criminal negligence and the child abuse results in any injury other than serious bodily injury to the child, it is a class 2 misdemeanor.
                    (b) Where no death or injury results, the following shall apply: 
                            (I) An act of child abuse when a person acts knowingly or recklessly is a class 2 misdemeanor.
                            (II) An act of child abuse when a person acts with criminal negligence is a class 3 misdemeanor.
                    (c) When a person knowingly causes the death of a child who has not yet attained twelve years of age and the person committing the offense is one in a position of trust with respect to the child, such person commits the crime of murder in the first degree as described in section 18-3-102(1)(f).
                    (d) When a person commits child abuse as described in paragraph (c) of subsection (1) of this section, it is a class 3 felony.
        (7.3) Felony child abuse is an extraordinary risk crime that is subject to the modified presumptive sentencing range specified in section 18-1.3-401 (10). Misdemeanor child abuse is an extraordinary risk crime that is subject to the modified sentencing range specified in section
18-1.3-501 (3).
        (7.5) If a defendant is convicted of the class 2 or class 3 felony of child abuse under subparagraph (I) or (III) of paragraph (a) of subsection (7) of this section, the court shall sentence the defendant in accordance with section 18-1.3-401(8)(d).
        (8) Repealed.
        (9) If a parent is charged with permitting a child to be unreasonably placed in a situation that poses a threat of injury to the child's life or health, pursuant to paragraph (a) of subsection (1) of this section, and the child was seventy-two hours old or younger at the time of the alleged offense, it shall be an affirmative defense to such charge that the parent safely, reasonably, and knowingly handed the child over to a firefighter, as defined in section 18-3-201(1), or to a hospital staff member who engages in the admission, care, or treatment of patients, when such firefighter is at a fire station or such hospital staff member is at a hospital.

CHILD ABUSE JUVENILE COURT DEPENDENCY AND NEGLECT ACTION

        In addition to the criminal charge, at minimum the driver and his or her family will be visited by a DHS caseworker to determine whether the child involved or any other children in the family are at risk and dependent and neglected.  In the discretion of the DHS caseworker, the child(ren) may be removed from the home, and a juvenile dependency and neglect lawsuit may be initiated.  Alternatively, the caseworker may leave the child(ren) in the home, but will make a finding regarding the report of child abuse.
        The immediate concern of any assessment or investigation shall be the protection of the child, and, where possible, the preservation of the family unit. 

CRS 19-3-308

DHS Investigation and Findings

CRS 19-3-401 and CRS 19-3-408

Removal of Child(ren) from Home

CRS 19-3-308

Retention of Child(ren) in Home

CRS 19-3-312

Juvenile Court Dependency & Neglect Action

CRS 19-3-304

Persons Required to Report Child Abuse or Neglect

CRS 19-3-311

Privileged Communications Abrogated (do not exist)

CRS 19-3-102. Neglected or dependent child.
        (1) A child is neglected or dependent if:
            (a) A parent, guardian, or legal custodian has abandoned the child or has subjected him or her to mistreatment or abuse or a parent, guardian, or legal custodian has suffered or allowed another to mistreat or abuse the child without taking lawful means to stop such mistreatment or abuse and prevent it from recurring;
            (b) The child lacks proper parental care through the actions or omissions of the parent, guardian, or legal custodian;
            (c) The child's environment is injurious to his or her welfare;
            (d) A parent, guardian, or legal custodian fails or refuses to provide the child with proper or necessary subsistence, education, medical care, or any other care necessary for his or her health, guidance, or well-being;
            (e) The child is homeless, without proper care, or not domiciled with his or her parent, guardian, or legal custodian through no fault of such parent, guardian, or legal custodian;
            (f) The child has run away from home or is otherwise beyond the control of his or her parent, guardian, or legal custodian;
            (g) The child tests positive at birth for either a schedule-I controlled substance, as defined in section 18-18-203, C.R.S., or a schedule-II controlled substance, as defined in section 18-18-204, C.R.S., unless the child tests positive for a schedule-II controlled substance as a result of the mother's lawful intake of such substance as prescribed.
        (2) A child is neglected or dependent if:
            (a) A parent, guardian, or legal custodian has subjected another child or children to an identifiable pattern of habitual abuse; and
            (b) Such parent, guardian, or legal custodian has been the respondent in another proceeding under this article in which a court has adjudicated another child to be neglected or dependent based upon allegations of sexual or physical abuse, or a court of competent jurisdiction has determined that such parent's, guardian's, or legal custodian's abuse or neglect has caused the death of another child; and
            (c) The pattern of habitual abuse described in paragraph (a) of this subsection (2) and the type of abuse described in the allegations specified in paragraph (b) of this subsection (2) pose a current threat to the child.

CRS 19-1-103. Definitions.  
            As used in this title or in the specified portion of this title, unless the context otherwise requires:
            (1)    (a) "Abuse" or "child abuse or neglect", as used in part 3 of article 3 of this title, means an act or omission in one of the following categories that threatens the health or welfare of a child:
                        (I) Any case in which a child exhibits evidence of skin bruising, bleeding, malnutrition, failure to thrive, burns, fracture of any bone, subdural hematoma, soft tissue swelling, or death and either: Such condition or death is not justifiably explained; the history given concerning such condition is at variance with the degree or type of such condition or death; or the circumstances indicate that such condition may not be the product of an accidental occurrence; 
                        (II) Any case in which a child is subjected to unlawful sexual behavior as defined in section 16-22-102(9), C.R.S.;
                        (III) Any case in which a child is a child in need of services because the child's parents, legal guardian, or custodian fails to take the same actions to provide adequate food, clothing, shelter, medical care, or supervision that a prudent parent would take. The requirements of this subparagraph (III) shall be subject to the provisions of section 19-3-103.
                        (IV) Any case in which a child is subjected to emotional abuse. As used in this subparagraph (IV), "emotional abuse" means an identifiable and substantial impairment of the child's intellectual or psychological
functioning or development or a substantial risk of impairment of the child's intellectual or psychological functioning or development.
                        (V) Any act or omission described in section 19-3-102(1)(a), (1)(b), or (1)(c);
                        (VI) Any case in which, in the presence of a child, or on the premises where a child is found, or where a child resides, a controlled substance, as defined in section 18-18-102(5), C.R.S., is manufactured or attempted to be manufactured;
                        (VII) Any case in which a child tests positive at birth for either a schedule-I controlled substance, as defined in section 18-18-203, C.R.S., or a schedule-II controlled substance, as defined in section 18-18-204,
C.R.S., unless the child tests positive for a schedule-II controlled substance as a result of the mother's lawful intake of such substance as prescribed.
            (b) In all cases, those investigating reports of child abuse shall take into account accepted child-rearing practices of the culture in which the child participates including, but not limited to, accepted work-related practices of agricultural communities. Nothing in this subsection (1) shall refer to acts that could be construed to be a reasonable exercise of parental discipline or to acts reasonably necessary to subdue a child being taken into custody pursuant to section 19-2-502 that are performed by a peace officer, as described in section 16-2.5-101, C.R.S., acting in the good faith performance of the officer's duties.

CHILD ABUSE CENTRAL REGISTRY

        The DHS will consider the breath alcohol concentration or blood alcohol concentration and the state's evidence in the criminal case.  The DHS caseworker will likely conduct independent investigation interviews and submit findings.  In determining whether to consider the child abuse report to be true, the DHS will use preponderance of the evidence as the standard of proof - more likely than not.

        If the DHS determines that the allegation is a confirmed report of child abuse or neglect, a report will be made to the statewide DHS central registry identifying the driver as a child abuser.  CRS 19-3-307.  The person who is the subject of the confirmed report may request a hearing under the administrative procedures act (APA) before an administrative law judge to challenge the confirmed report finding and inclusion in the DHS child abuse central registry.  The subject of the report may file a petition for exclusion (expungement or sealing) under the APA. CRS 24-4-105.  The hearing officer's findings are subject to judicial review under the APA.  CRS 24-4-106.

For additional information refer to:

Investigation & report of child abuse or neglect

CRS 19-3-307, 12 CCR 2509-3 § 7.202.5

Confirmed reports of child abuse or neglect

CRS 19-3-313.5, 12 CCR 2509-3 § 7.202.6

Access to confirmed reports of child abuse or neglect

CRS 19-1-307, 12 CCR 2509-1 § 7.000.72

County DHS - conflict resolution

CRS 19-3-211, 12 CCR 2509-3 § 7.200.3

State reviews of county records & state level hearing

CRS 19-3-313.5, 12 CCR 2509-3 § 7.202.6

        In Colorado, if a driver is under the influence of alcohol or any drug (prescription or illicit) and serious bodily injury or death results to any person in an accident, the driver may be charged with and found guilty of vehicular assault CRS 18-3-205 or vehicular homicide CRS 18-3-106.  The defendant's intoxication and impaired driving must be the proximate (legal) cause, however all that is required of the drinking driver is simple negligence or carelessness if the driver's actions or conduct contributed to the injury or death.

        Contributory negligence of the victim is not a defense.  The injured person or a third person may be the primary cause; this does not affect criminal liability.  If a driver were to be involved in such an accident, the District Attorney Office would likely charge the felony if a driver's BAC is 0.08 or greater, and the driver could be charged on a lower BAC or without a chemical test.

        Felony conviction may result in sentence to the Colorado Department of Corrections - state penitentiary.  Every person has the potential to be charged with either of these felonies any time he / she drives a motor vehicle after consuming alcohol.  No warning alarms sound nor do lights flash when a driver's BAC reaches 0.05 or 0.08 grams of alcohol per 210 liters of breath or per 100 ml of blood. No defendant has the right to refuse a chemical test when charged with a felony; blood will be drawn involuntarily if need be.

        CRS 18-3-205 Vehicular Assault  (F-4) or (F-5) depending upon facts Refer to:
        CRS 18-3-106 Vehicular Homicide (F-3) CRS 18-1.3-401 Felony Sentencing

ATTORNEY'S ROLE AND ASSISTANCE

   
DUI DEFENSE
COLORADO SPRINGS DEFENSE ATTORNEY
 

        To learn the facts from the client's viewpoint, the attorney conducts a factual interview.  The interview frequently takes 1 - 11/2 hours.  To glean evidence of which the client may not be aware, I will investigate each DUI case prior to pre-trial conference negotiation or contested proceedings of motions hearing and trial.

        During investigation in a criminal case, counsel looks for evidence:
                exculpatory evidence tends to negate guilt or to reduce punishment
                inculpatory evidence tends to establish or support guilt or to increase punishment
                investigation preceding contested proceedings is more in-depth, which may involve a private investigator

        While most evidence can be discovered at nominal cost, re-testing DUI breath or blood alcohol and drug screening or toxicology by an independent laboratory requires out of pocket expense.  Re-testing is not required, but strongly advised - the attorney seeks to uncover any weakness in the state's case.  No attorney can manufacture or destroy evidence, but a competent attorney certainly can discover.

 
ATTORNEY'S ROLE AND ASSISTANCE
F
irst Offense - Known BAC 0.169 or Less
Potential Quotes - Attorney Fees & Costs
Criminal Case DMV Hearing
 

        Pre-trail conference proceedings (plea negotiations) are set in first offense DUI cases where the BAC is 0.169 or below.  After investigating the case, determining the evidence and facts, and applying relevant law, I plea bargain with prosecutors to obtain the most favorable offer possible.  I ask that clients be present in the courthouse to discuss the plea negotiation offer, consequences of acceptance, possible alternatives, facts and law applicable to trial.  The attorney makes recommendations if requested.  After receiving sufficient information to make an intelligent decision, the client is asked whether to accept the plea offer, or proceed to trial. It is the client's DUI case and consequences - the client will be able to decide freely, voluntarily and intelligently.  After the client's decision, if settled I set a sentencing hearing, or if unresolved - I schedule motions hearing, readiness hearing and trial.

        The attorney's role in this type of DUI case is fact finder and negotiator - hopefully trial will not be required.  A difficulty with blood test DUI cases is that the BAC is generally not known at the time of hire.

 
ATTORNEY'S ROLE AND ASSISTANCE
F
irst Offense - BAC 0.17+ * BAC Unknown * BAC Refusal * CDL
or
Second or Subsequent Offense
Potential Quotes - Attorney Fees & Costs
Criminal Case DMV Hearing
 

        If a blood test was conducted, the results will not be known to the driver or state for a period of time.  Under Department of Heatlh Regulation 5 CCR 1005-2, the state lab has 15 days in which to test the blood.  A defendant may appear at the Colorado Springs Police Department POC and request blood test results.  A small fee may be assessed by the CSPD Crime Lab.  Defense counsel will obtain discovery from the DA Office during the course of investigation which will include BAC test results, gas chromatograph charts, chain of custody, lab certification & documentary certification.  Similarly, if a breath test was taken, defense counsel will request and receive the intoxilyzer printout evidencing BAC result, intoxilyzer certification, operator certification, instructor certification, and documentary certification.  The BAC test results will in large part determine the course of defense of defense strategy.  First offense unknown BAC which is determined to be 0.169 or less will result in attorney flat fee adjustment.

 

        Sharp teeth have been added to Colorado law regarding DUI first offense cases involving BAC of 0.17+, BAC 0.2+, BAC refusal, second / subsequent offense, Adult CDL or Minor CDL.  These consequences take the the form of mandatory minimum jail sentences, DMV license loss or restrictions, persistent drunk driver, mandatory interlock and SR-22 Insurance plus the El Paso County District Attorney Office policies.  Refer to defense criteria & considerations below.  An attorney's role in this type of DUI case is trial attorney -  not negotiator.  Attorney now agrees to provide representation in most of these cases on a trial fee basis due to the fact settlement within parameters acceptable to the client is not possible.

        Numerous trials were required in the early 1980's when DUI law was forming, a "designer crime" or a "hot ticket item"

        Much of the DUI caselaw was decided, from the late 1970's - mid 1980's.  From the late 1980's - 2002 it was my belief that a ballpark of reason existed for each case, and settlement could be found in nearly every DUI - whether first offense or multiple offender, or whether aggravated or mitigated in BAC level, accident or other facts.

        Settlement negotiations are no longer worthwhile in DUI case involving a BAC of 0.17+, BAC refusal, second / subsequent offense, Adult CDL or Minor CDL unless conducted within the context of motion and trial settings.  The only settlement alternatives are to negotiate toward work release, home detention - ankle bracelet or day reporting.  This is based upon:

        Shift in El Paso County District Attorney Office settlement policy to mandatory imposition of jail, sometimes straight jail without work release. and
        Mandatory minimum jail sentences imposed by state statutes for cases involving BAC 0.20+ or second / subsequent offense, and
        Bear in mind settlement will likely not solve DMV license loss or restrictions

        DUI cases involving a BAC of 0.17+, BAC 0.20, BAC refusal, CDL or second / subsequent offense should be investigated and prepared for trial.  This is unfortunate as trial posture increases fees and costs, but unavoidable.  El Paso County District Attorney Office policy, DMV license or driving privilege consequences and current statutes leave no alternative.  Put another way - why pay an attorney to negotiate when this has become a non-negotiable circumstance?  Knowing this, If a prospective client requested defense on a negotiation toward jail, work release, day reporting or ankle bracelet,  and understands the license problems of persistent drunk driver, mandatory interlock and SR-22 Insurance, I would likely consider representation on that basis.

        Most settlement DUI cases do not require a subpoena duces tecum upon the law enforcement agency to obtain 911 or dispatch tapes, but trial cases do.  If required, an expense will be incurred to serve the subpoena duces tecum as well as an expense to the law enforcement agency for research and duplication of the calls on a CD, and preparation of a hardcopy call screen, otherwise known as CAD - computer assisted dispatch.

        Similar to subpoena above, most settlement DUI cases do not require the services of a private investigator, but trial cases do.  If so, an expense would be incurred to the investigator. I always obtain client authorization prior to utilizing such services. Witness statements may be taken from any law enforcement officer, medical or paramedic or lay witnesses who may testify.  A synopsis or transcript of the witness' statement is useful in trial preparation, as well as for impeachment purpose at trial or hearing.  Counsel can not testify in any case in which representation is provided.  It is also common for the investigator to photograph the scene.  An investigator looks for all evidence - favorable and unfavorable.  This attorney does not wish to be surprised at trial.  If investigation is merited, I request a trust deposit to cover expenses for a private investigator 

        If a DMV revocation hearing is held, a DMV transcript of the officer's testimony can be obtained whether the ruling is taken on appeal or not.  This is beneficial at motion hearing and trial: it may be used for impeachment of officer prior inconsistent statement or lack of recollection.  The DMV transcriptionist will require a transcript deposit.

        If a favorable settlement offer is made, it is usually on the eve of trial or as the jury panel is being brought to the courtroom from the jury commissioner.  Chances are very slim that a DUI case of this nature will settle within parameters acceptable to the client unless he / she favors the idea of jail, significant public service and alcohol education + therapy as well as monitored Rx disulfiram (antabuse) and monitored abstinence.  Don't expect negotiation to disposition - trial is likely.  It is likely the Deputy DA will not have authority or ability to negotiate a settlement which will avoid DMV license loss or restrictions.  Even if negotiated, multiple offense cases and BAC 0.20+ cases carry mandatory jail.

        Judges may inquire whether the parties have attempted negotiation.  The court can not and will not attempt to force a settlement, but judges like to know that settlement options have been explored prior to expending valuable court time.  It is this attorney's policy to call the Deputy DA shortly before contested proceedings to discuss potential settlement, even if unlikely. 

        Plea negotiations are impacted by evidentiary or legal weaknesses.  At any time a settlement offer is received, the client is advised of the offer, facts, applicable law, consequences and options in order that he / she may make intelligent decisions.  It is the client's case and consequences, therefore he / she must always be able to decide freely, voluntarily and intelligently.  The client's decision is always honored, even if counsel recommends otherwise.

FACTORS - INITIAL DEFENSE POSTURE & FEES / COSTS
criteria upon which attorney & client decide how to proceed in a DUI case
jail & license restrictions are foremost concerns to most clients
(bear in mind this crystal ball tends to be a bit hazy - predicting the future is best left to fortune tellers & soothsayers)

 

*  First DUI Offense - BAC 0.169 or Less.  If retained, attorney will likely schedule a pre-trial conference.  Settlement would be anticipated.
First offense BAC 0.05 - 0.79
 
 

NO DMV proceedings statutorily initiated
     no jail mandatory per statute - refer to DA policy
     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs

   
First offense BAC 0.08 - 0.169
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - revocation - BAC 0.08 - 0.169
     no jail mandatory per statute - refer to DA policy
     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
First offense BAC refusal
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - BAC refusal revocation
     no jail mandatory per statute - refer to DA policy - increased trial probability
     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

 

****************************** ****************************** ******************************
 
*  First DUI Offense - BAC 0.17 or Greater or 2nd / Subsequent Offenses.  If retained, attorney will likely not set a pre-trial conference, but instead set subpoena return dates, motions hearing, readiness hearing, and trial.  Jury trial would be anticipated.
First offense BAC 0.17 - 0.199
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock.
     refer to DA policy
     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
First offense BAC 0.20 or greater
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
     refer to mandatory jail

     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
Second or subsequent offense
     outside 5 years
 
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - revocation - BAC 0.08 - 0.169
refer to DMV proceedings -  revocation - BAC 017 or Greater
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock

     refer to mandatory jail
     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
Second offense within 5 years
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - 2nd offense within 5 years
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
refer to DMV proceedings - revocation - BAC 0.08 - 0.169
refer to DMV proceedings -  revocation - BAC 017 or Greater
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
     refer to mandatory jail

     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
Third offense within lifetime
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - 3rd offense within lifetime
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock

refer to DMV proceedings - revocation - BAC 0.08 - 0.169
refer to DMV proceedings -  revocation - BAC 017 or Greater
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
     refer to mandatory jail

     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
Third or subsequent offense
     within 7 years
 
 
 
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - habitual offender
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock

refer to DMV proceedings - revocation - BAC 0.08 - 0.169
refer to DMV proceedings -  revocation - BAC 017 or Greater
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
     refer to mandatory jail

     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
Second or Subsequent Offense
     BAC refusal
 
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - BAC refusal revocation
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock

refer also to 2nd offense, 3rd offense lifetime or habitual offender above
     refer to mandatory jail

     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

 

****************************** ****************************** ******************************

 

*  CDL - Commercial Driver License.  If retained, attorney will likely not set a pre-trial conference, but instead set subpoena return dates, motions hearing, readiness hearing, and trial.  Jury trial would be anticipated.
Adult CDL - any BAC or refusal
     First offense
 
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - out of service order, disqualification, reinstatement
     refer to DA policy
     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

Minor CDL - any BAC or refusal
     First offense
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - out of service order, disqualification, reinstatement
     refer to DA policy

     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

Second or subsequent offense

consult the attorney

 

****************************** ****************************** ******************************

  

*  Minors Involved in Alcohol Related Cases - First Offense.  If retained, attorney will likely schedule a pre-trial conference.  Settlement would be anticipated.
"Baby DUI" - BAC 0.02 - 0.05
     First offense
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - "Baby DEAC" revocation
refer to DMV proceedings - conviction revocation
If MIP charged - refer to DMV proceedings - revocation
     refer to TI -Class A     CRS 42-4-1301(2)(a.5)(I)
     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
Underage alcohol
     First offense BAC 0.05 - 0.169
 
 

 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - "Baby DEAC" revocation 0.05 - 0.079
refer to DMV proceedings - DEAC revocation 0.08 - 0.169
refer to DMV proceedings - conviction revocation
If MIP charged - refer to DMV proceedings - revocation
     refer to DA policy

     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
Underage alcohol
     First offense BAC 0.17 - 0.199
    
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
refer to DMV proceedings - conviction revocation
If MIP charged - refer to DMV proceedings - revocation
     refer to DA policy

     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
Underage alcohol
     First offense BAC 0.20 or greater
    
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
refer to DMV proceedings - conviction revocation
If MIP charged - refer to DMV proceedings - revocation
     refer to mandatory jail

     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
Underage alcohol
     First offense BAC refusal
    
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - refusal revocation
refer to DMV proceedings - conviction revocation
If MIP charged - refer to DMV proceedings - revocation
     no jail mandatory per statute - DA policy - increased trial probability
     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

 
****************************** ****************************** ******************************

 

*  Minors Involved in Alcohol Related Cases - Second Offense.  If retained, attorney will likely not set a pre-trial conference, but instead set subpoena return dates, motions hearing, readiness hearing, and trial.    Jury trial would be anticipated.
"Baby DUI" - BAC 0.02 - 0.05
     Second or subsequent offense
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - revocation
If MIP charged - refer to DMV proceedings - revocation
     refer to T2 -Class 2     CRS 42-4-1301(2)(a.5)(II)

     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
Underage alcohol
     Second or subsequent offense
     BAC 0.05 - 0.169

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - "Baby DEAC" revocation 0.05 - 0.079
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
refer to DMV proceedings - DEAC revocation 0.08 - 0.169
refer to DMV proceedings - conviction revocation - prior not within 5 years
refer to DMV proceedings - revocation 2nd conviction within 5 years
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
refer to DMV proceedings - revocation 3rd conviction within lifetime
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
refer to DMV proceedings - habitual offender revocation - 3 offenses - 7 years
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
If MIP charged - refer to DMV proceedings - revocation
     refer to mandatory jail

     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
Underage alcohol
     Second or subsequent offense
     BAC 0.17 - 0.199
 
 
 
 

 
 
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - DEAC revocation 0.17 or Greater
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
refer to DMV proceedings - conviction revocation - prior not within 5 years
refer to DMV proceedings - revocation 2nd conviction within 5 years
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
refer to DMV proceedings - revocation 3rd conviction within lifetime
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
refer to DMV proceedings - habitual offender revocation - 3 offenses - 7 years
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
If MIP charged - refer to DMV proceedings - revocation
     refer to mandatory jail

     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
Underage alcohol
     Second or subsequent offense
     BAC 0.20 or greater
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - DEAC revocation 0.17 or Greater
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
refer to DMV proceedings - conviction revocation - prior not within 5 years
refer to DMV proceedings - revocation 2nd conviction within 5 years
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
refer to DMV proceedings - revocation 3rd conviction within lifetime
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
refer to DMV proceedings - habitual offender revocation - 3 offenses - 7 years
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
If MIP charged - refer to DMV proceedings - revocation
     refer to mandatory jail

     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

   
Underage alcohol
     Second or subsequent offense
     BAC refusal
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

refer to DMV proceedings - refusal revocation
refer to DMV proceedings - conviction revocation - prior not within 5 years
refer to DMV proceedings - revocation 2nd conviction within 5 years
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
refer to DMV proceedings - revocation 3rd conviction within lifetime
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
refer to DMV proceedings - habitual offender revocation - 3 offenses - 7 years
               persistent drunk driver - mandatory interlock
If MIP charged - refer to DMV proceedings - revocation
     refer to mandatory jail
     refer to potential quote for criminal case fees and costs
     refer to potential quote for DMV hearing fees and costs

COLORADO DUI DEFENSE
 
POTENTIAL DEFENSES
caveat - more law is applicable - just a brief overview here
TRAFFIC - MISDEMEANOR OFFENSE
DUI 12 Points  **  DEAC 12 Points  **  DWAI 8 Points

        When a defendant is presented with some of the following evidence of probable cause or intoxication on the merits, a DUI case can appear indefensible.

driving pattern, weaving, go fast speeding, stop sign or red light violation, prior erratic driving described by third party witness, motor vehicle accident, attempt to leave scene & witness' seizure of keys, lack of explanation as to what happened to cause accident, strong odor of alcohol, face flushed, eyes bloodshot & watery, speech slurred & thick tongue, admissions by defendant, request, plea or begging to be let go, admission of intoxication to a degree the driver is a danger to himself and others, 2 beers statement or denial of consumption inconsistent with driving & behavioral observations (smell like a brewery or distillery), admission no alcohol consumption since driving, admission of medication at time of arrest, Rx warnings or labels, other drugs found time of arrest - marijuana or roaches, prior alcohol traffic arrests / convictions, prior drug arrests / convictions, prior misdemeanor or felony arrests / convictions, spacial disorientation as to date and time - where located where been where going, lack of physical coordination - falling down, difficulty walking or maintaining balance, fumbling for driver's license / registration or insurance or inability to produce and I could go on - the above list doesn't even begin to touch roadside sobriety tests, BAC testing, etc.

        Some DUI cases are indefensible at trial, however most are defensible.  I've included a short list of issues counsel reviews, but have attempted to exclude defenses which could skewer the facts reported by a defendant to counsel during an interview.  Defense preparation should fit the facts, not the client making the facts fit potential defenses.

  1. Jurisdictional attack  - refer to link for information regarding DUI cases
            Attack the jurisdiction (power) of the court in the pending criminal case
            Jurisdictional attack may be an important concept in defense of any given DUI case

  2. Lack of reasonable suspicion for initial contact by the law enforcement officer

  3. Law enforcement officers belong at an accident scene and officers find it impolite when a driver runs the light.  Weaving is a common reason for initial stop - nearly impossible to defend reasonable suspicion because there is seldom a windmill witness to the initial driving pattern.

  4. Lack of probable cause for warrantless arrest or seizure of the defendant's person

  5. Roadside tests unreasonable search unsupported by warrant.  DUI roadside sobriety testing is a search in the constitutional sense which can and should be refused whether intoxicated or stone cold sober.  Law enforcement officers have no obligation to advise you of your right to refuse roadside testing, but it exists - a simple no and request for counsel works quite well.

  6. Chemical testing unreasonable search unsupported by warrant

  7. Unreliable chemical testing violative of due process

  8. Unlawful extra-jurisdictional arrest

  9. Defendant's admissions the result of undue influence, duress and coercion - due process violation

  10. Defendant's admissions taken in violation of
            5th Amendment privilege against self incrimination
            6th Amendment right to legal counsel

  11. Chemical testing failed to comply with Colorado law & Dept. of Health regulations

  12. Alleged offense did not occur on public roadway or highway? - sorry, won't work in DUI cases

  13. Driving
            A third person, not defendant, was driving a motor vehicle

  14. Defendant's action's did not constitute driving as defined by Colorado law
            42-1-102(27) "Driver" means every person, including a minor driver under the age of twenty-one years, who drives or is in actual physical control of a vehicle

  15. Officer observations - what didn't he observe which a jury member might expect?  What was the officer's opportunity to observe? - lighting, time spent, temperature, etc.  

  16. Officer credibility.  Experience with DUI enforcement and training, over concern with conviction statistics, a cop's cop or an average Joe doing a job, would the jury members want this particular officer stopping him / her?  Has the officer overstated his / her observations in relation to the BAC?  How well was the stop and investigation conducted?

  17. Roadside sobriety testing - was it truly "voluntary," advisement which was given, it a search within the meaning of constitutional protections - was there probable cause, was it reasonable?  Were there legitimate reasons other than alcohol for poor performance?  Was horizontal gaze nystagmus (HGN) properly conducted or could an eye doctor discredit the test as conducted?  Was HGN conducted after midnight - HGN onsought effect.  What tests didn't the negligent officer conduct?

  18. Breath BAC.  Consent "voluntary?" Did the officer observe the defendant for a full 20 minutes to avoid residual mouth alcohol?  Dentures, plates or periodontal pockets?  Certification of the intoxilyzer operator, instructor and machine?  Spiking, malfunction, blood-gas ratio average not particularized to defendant, physical inability to cycle, retention of a silica jell tube, specimen re-test results & variance, standard solution - time used, date of preparation, number of times used, standard solution results from other tests, ambient air alcohol, radio wave interference.  How long from time of driving, how was the time of driving established?  Cycle sequence, etc.

  19. Blood BAC.  Voluntary consent?  Vial 1.0+% NaFl as anti-coagulent and preservative?  Sterility in vial and skin?  Was ethanol based sterilant used to swab skin?  Specimen re-test results & variance, is BAC result highest of multiple state tests or average or low test result?  Refridgeration, officer presence at the time of the draw, time between blood draw and testing, chain of custody and witnesses thereto, vial identification, phlebotomist / lab tech / toxicologist / pathologist, lab certification, vial serial number matches - ID, etc.

  20. Reasonable doubt - state proof beyond a reasonable doubt

  21. Cloak of innocence and burden of proof upon state - beyond a reasonable doubt.  A defendant is not required to prove innocence - the state must prove guilt.

  22. Voluntary Intoxication is an affirmative defense to criminal charges requiring scienter (specific intent), but DUI, DEAC or DWAI are strict liability crimes and the defense is not available.  If it were, voluntary intoxication would probably not be the best defense to the charge of intoxication.

  23. Involuntary Intoxication (i.e.: spiked punch - consumption of alcohol without knowledge) would be an affirmative defense to DUI, DEAC or DWAI charges.  A jury returned a not guilty verdict for one of my clients on the spiked punch issue - the state failed to prove knowing consumption.
            Knowing consumption argument - vodka spiked punch unbeknownst to "victimized" defendant

  24. I could ramble on, but it should be clear a multitude of facts are available for cross examination.  An example of a couple unusual, but available defenses may be accessed:  Sample Defenses page.

  25. When all else fails:

  26. Trial lawyer's adage:
            If the facts are on your side - pound the facts.
            If the law is on your side - pound the law.
            If neither the facts nor the law are on your side - pound the table !

  27. And if that fails ---- quote to the jury what one of my 1982 western slope DUI trial clients said to the state trooper in response to the trooper's question:  "Doin' a little weaving there, weren't ya fella?"
                    Client:  Whaddaya schpect?   I'm drrrrunk !!

INDEPENDENT SERVICE PROVIDERS
private investigators * process service * laboratories * transcription
refer to attorney-client privilege and attorney work product doctrine

ADVICE BY LAYMEN
forewarned is forearmed
advice by unsupervised paralegals & street corner lawyers

TRAFFIC DEFENSE

DUI - DWAI - DEAC  *  Driving Under Restraint  *  No Operator's License  *  Speeding DMV DEFENSE DMV Appeal
Speed Contest - Drag Racing  *  Eluding Police  *  Hit & Run  *  Compulsory Insurance License Hearings * Point Structure * Forms
Reckless Driving - Careless Driving  *    *  Weaving - Roadways Laned for Traffic Habitual Offender  *  Interstate Compact
Minor - Alcohol Red Light - Stop Sign  *  Traffic Definitions  *  Traffic Infraction vs. Crime  *  Traffic Cams Insurance SR-22 Interlock  Driving Records
 

COLORADO DUI DEFENSE
DO I NEED AN ATTORNEY?

 
Do I need an attorney?

Probably time to loosen the pocket book and hire a defense attorney.

   
 

Each alcohol related traffic charge carries 8 points to 12 points
     DWAI may cause license point suspension - 8 points
     DUI or DEAC will cause license point suspension - 12 points each charge
Potential independent DMV adverse actions
     excessive alcohol revocation or chemical test refusal revocation
     persistent drunk driver - BAC 0.17 first or subsequent offence  **  multiple offender
     mandatory interlock
     SR-22 requirement
Each alcohol related traffic charge carries potential jail
     BAC 0.20 carries mandatory jail
Each alcohol related traffic charge is a major offense for habitual offender purposes
Any alcohol related traffic charge would likely cause large insurance premium increase or potential cancellation
 
You may retain my services or the services of another attorney, but hire defense counsel

 

If convicted of any alcohol related traffic offense, you could anticipate policy termination or significant increase in your insurance premiums - probably over a period of 3 - 5 years.  Contact your insurance company underwriters to learn more of the potential consequences.

ATTORNEY'S FEES AND COSTS
DUI DEFENSE  *  DWAI DEFENSE  *  DEAC DEFENSE
criminal law trial practice drunk driving defense 25 years

 

 

        At the time of the first visit, a prospective client will be quoted attorney's fees and estimated costs. The quote will be honored for a period of seven (7) days, after which it is subject to change without notice if this office has not been retained.  Attorney is a sole practitioner with need to manage his caseload.  Pending proposed client acceptance and payment, retainer agreement proposals are subject to withdrawal.  Attorney reserves the right to decline any case.
 
        In most circumstances, attorney initially makes an option offer of 1.) billing to be upon hourly fees, or in the alternative, 2.) quote of a settlement flat fee or a trial flat fee.  Attorney reserves the right to quote hourly fees only without a flat fee offer, or hourly and trial flat fee options only. 
ELECTION. Offered fee options will be up to the client, however client's initial election will be final.
 
        Included in attorney's primary website is a web page devoted to clear definition & understanding of free
first consultation, fees and costs, retainer agreement and terms of representation.  Additional information regarding fees & costs may be found via the links following potential quotes.

POTENTIAL FEE QUOTE
DUI DEFENSE  *  DWAI DEFENSE  *  DEAC DEFENSE

FIRST OFFENSE - KNOWN BAC 0.169 OR LESS

SETTLEMENT FLAT FEE
settlement fee paid deducted from trial flat fee
$1,500*
 
*estimate n/a child abuse - consult attorney
TRIAL FLAT FEE
settlement fee paid deducted from trial flat fee
$5,500*
 
*estimate n/a child abuse - consult attorney

Most DUI first offense cases with a BAC 0.169 or less plea bargain and do not proceed to trial.  The settlement flat fee would be dependent upon the facts and circumstances of the case, however the above would be a common quote.  This shall neither constitute an offer, nor be construed as a binding estimate.

HOURLY FEE RATE
trust deposit request regarding fees & costs
 

PAYMENT

Prior to commencement of representation, the attorney will quote the amount requested as a trust deposit against which attorney's fees and costs may be billed.  The requested trust deposit will be dependent upon the facts and circumstances of your case.

Colorado Springs Attorney Robert D. Gustafson
ATTORNEY FEES

LITIGATION COSTS DEPOSIT
 
$        1,500      
$           350      
 
settlement common trust deposit request
including attorney's fees & litigation costs - excluding travel
*n/a child abuse - consult attorney
map * travel policy - time & expenses * travel rates
settlement trust deposit would be deducted from trial trust deposit
 

OR

$1,850*

 

Colorado Springs Attorney Robert D. Gustafson
ATTORNEY FEES

LITIGATION COSTS DEPOSIT
 
$        5,500    
$        1,500    
 
trial common trust deposit request
including attorney's fees & litigation costs - excluding travel
Additional cost deposit may be requested as trial preparation proceeds &
anticipated litigation expenses solidify
*n/a child abuse - consult attorney
map * travel policy - time & expenses * travel rates
settlement trust deposit would be deducted from trial trust deposit

$7,000*

first alcohol offense - known BAC 0.169 or less
* this shall not constitute an offer, nor be construed as a binding estimate

Client authorization is obtained for any large cost expense.  Final expenditure may run less or client may periodically be asked for additional amounts to be deposited to trust if fees and costs will exceed previous deposits. 

Client will be provided with a trust accounting and itemized billing statement when there has been activity on the account.  At the end of each case, a detailed accounting summary is provided and remaining trust proceeds are refunded.

trust deposit for anticipated fees & costs is due when retained

attorney does not accept installment payments

regular billings are scheduled on the 1st and 15th
if fees and costs are not paid as agreed, representation is withdrawn

 
PARTIAL LIST OF POTENTIAL COSTS
out of pocket costs are the responsibility of the client
note: costs change & below cost information may be obsolete
link to Colorado Judicial Branch website -  current costs information published by state
COLORADO STATE COURT COSTS
direct link to criminal or traffic court costs - costs change & lists may be obsolete
COUNTY COURT CRIMINAL COSTS DISTRICT COURT CRIMINAL COSTS
    Alcohol or Substance Testing & Testimony
160.00   Toxicology - BAC Ethanol (alcohol) only
210.00   Toxicology - BAC Ethanol (alcohol) + NaFl (preservative)
consult counsel or lab
 
  Toxicology - UA qualitative or quantitative toxicology screen for marijuana, substance quantitative toxicology screen for marijuana or
                         qualitative and quantitative drug screen
3,000
 
  Laboratory - Toxicologist testimony hourly fees and travel mileage  -  if expert testimony relevant  -  rates as of 5/24/05
                          misdemeanor hourly rate $350 - 5 hours travel time + minimum 1.5 hours court time
    Other Potential Expenses
Price   Client Background Search
Varies   DMV Out of State Driving Record
10.00   Accident Report
20.00   Offense Report
10.00   DA Office discovery packet - estimate (actual may be more or less)
25.00   State court jury deposit (DWAI only) C.R.Crim.P. 23, CRS 16-10-109 (non-refundable except by acquittal)
10.00   Court records search & copy costs (actual may be more or less)
10.00   Copy expense at courthouse for prior offense files (estimate - may vary)
75.00   Public Service supervision fee
37.50   OJW fee to court (outstanding judgment warrant) - anticipating Integral Recoveries collection agency referral costs
95.00   DMV reinstatement fee
4.40   DMV clearance letter - certified copy of Colorado driving abstract
500.00   Private Investigator initial retainer - if relevant - variable based upon number of witnesses to interview
200.00   Law enforcement 911 / dispatch records, tapes & transcript - widely variable
200.00   Subpoena process service expense - depends on number of subpoenas issued
$3 per page   Transcriptionist - law enforcement 911 / dispatch audio files & investigator interview audio recordings if relevant
Varies   On-line legal research - dependent upon issues requiring legal research, if any
Rates   Travel time and expenses if the case is outside El Paso County
    depending upon the facts and severity of charges, it may be prudent to retain an accident reconstruction expert

Depending upon the facts, it may be prudent to place law enforcement 911 * dispatch tapes and records, plus other law enforcement records under subpoena duces tecum.  Expense will depend upon the amount of time the law enforcement agency spends searching dispatch tapes and records.

CAVEAT: Not all above costs will be relevant to any given case, and additional expenses not identified may be incurred in any individual case.  Costs quoted are subject to change by independent providers; actual costs paid will be billed.  limited search pricing

 
 
****************************** ****************************** ******************************
 
POTENTIAL FEE QUOTE
DUI DEFENSE  *  DWAI DEFENSE  *  DEAC DEFENSE